Lindsey Cardinale was a top 12 finalist during the 2005 season of American Idol. A good friend to Carrie during her brief stay in the competition, Lindsey was the first contestant voted off the show in the top 12.
Week # Song choice Original artist Result
Top 24 "Standing Right Next to Me" Karla Bonoff Safe
Top 20 "I Try to Think About Elvis" Patty Loveless Safe
Top 16 "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" Aerosmith Safe
Top 12 "Knock on Wood" Eddie Floyd Eliminated