Week # Song Choice Original Artist Result
Top 24 "Kiss from a Rose" Seal Safe
Top 20 "Hard to Handle" Otis Redding Safe
Top 16 "Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic" The Police Safe
Top 12 "You've Made Me So Very Happy" Blood, Sweat & Tears Safe
Top 11 "I Think I Love You" The Partridge Family Safe
Top 10 "I Can't Make You Love Me" Bonnie Raitt Safe
Top 9 "My Funny Valentine" Richard Rodgers/Lorenz Hart Safe
Top 8 "Bohemian Rhapsody" Queen Safe
Top 7 "Nights on Broadway" The Bee Gees Safe
Top 6 "How You Remind Me" Nickelback Eliminated

Constantine Maroulis was a finalist on Carrie's season of American Idol. Known for his looks and rock approach, he was voted off the show during the top 6 week

After the show, Constantine made his debut on broadway, and received a Tony nomination for his performance in Rock of Ages.